For the second time on American Idol this season, Casey Abrams was pegged for elimination. This week though, there was no save available for the judges and Casey was sent home. The bearded 20-year old from Idyllwild was one of the more colorful contestants on the show. A true musician, Abrams could be counted on doing something dramatically different every week, whether it was singing Nirvana, playing the base, or kissing Jennifer Lopez.

After being shockingly saved in Top-11 week, Abrams didn’t face the Bottom Three again until this week when he joined Scotty McCreery and Jacob Lusk. While Abrams was extremely talented, his occasional growls and unusual style scared off some voters. Our very own Noah Duman was hoping Abrams would be eliminated after his rendition last night of Carole King’s “Hi-De-Ho”. Now, American can wonder if Casey’s rumored girlfriend Haley Reinhart will be the next to go.